16 handles

http://www.une-vie-saine.com/2011/07/16-handles.html

This place is one of the reasons why, when I graduated from college, I knew I wanted to move to New York. The froyo is amazing - sweet, light and satisfying - and the toppings' bar dangerously extensive. Most flavors range from 90 to 110 calories per 3 oz. My personal favorites: irish mint, chocolate eruption, graham cracker and snickerdoodle. And a quick tip: cinnamon toast crunch is surprisingly good on ice cream.

153 2nd Ave (b/w 9th and 10th)
1569 2nd Ave (b/w 81st and 82nd)
325 Amsterdam (b/w 75th and 76th)
website